Synergetic and sustainable policy mixes in water management

#policy #synergy #consistency #conflict #sustainable development goals
The figure shows a cross-impact matrix in which 14 goals and 2-5 alternative measures and instruments to achieve these goals are compared. It is a conceptual model in which interactions between different measures and instruments were assessed in pairs. Fostering effects are green, hindering effects are red, depending on the strength of the influence, the shade is darker. In addition, mutually exclusive relationships are marked with crosses. Cells without colour do not assume any influence between the respective measures. In addition to the goals and measures, the model also contains the influence of context conditions (here: governance variants) as active factors and SDG targets as passive factors. The example shows the network of interactions of water management measures in the Lurín river basin, Lima, Peru.
Matrix for the qualitative system analysis of interactions between measures and instruments in water management, using the example of the Lurín river basin, Lima, Peru. © ZIRIUS

The method is used to design and evaluate policy mixes to achieve different goals at the same time. It allows measuring the synergy and consistency of policy mixes, assessing sustainability effects as well as robustness, considering context uncertainty.

Water management is often faced with the challenge that different goals of various water users have to be achieved at the same time. Measures and instruments addressing these goals cannot be freely combined with one another. Instead, they mutually influence each other in terms of their effectiveness and can, for example, trigger conflicts in situations of water scarcity. This is where this method comes in.

With the help of the qualitative system analysis CIB (Cross-Impact Balances, Weimer-Jehle 2006), a conceptual model of interactions between measures to achieve different goals is created. Literature and knowledge from experts and/or stakeholders are used to assess the interactions. Hindering, fostering, neutral and mutually exclusive interactions are identified. The CIB balance algorithm in the freely available software SzenarioWizard then allows to  measure the synergy and consistency of policy mixes. As a result, synergetic and internally consistent policy mixes can be identified. In addition, the sustainability performance of various mixes can be assessed if sustainability criteria (e.g. SDG targets or indicators) and their interactions are integrated into the system model. Finally, the robustness of policy mixes can be assessed if context variants (e.g. governance, climate change) are integrated, too.
Overall, this is a qualitative but systematic approach to generate system-analytical knowledge about existing and possible alternative policy mixes. The method is a building block for coherent policy design processes in water management and planning.

Water resource: Drinking water, Groundwater, Process water, Rainwater, Salt water, Surface water, Treated water, Wastewater
Type of product:
  • Management concepts & assessments
  • Modelling & software tools
Application sector: Cities and municipalities, Water resource management
Funding measure: GRoW
Project: TRUST

Contact and partners

Zentrum für Interdisziplinäre Risiko- und Innovationsforschung der Universität
  • ZIRIUS Zentrum für Interdisziplinäre Risiko- und Innovationsforschung der Universität,
  • Seidenstr. 36,
  • 70174 Stuttgart
Dr. rer. pol. Hannah Kosow

ZIRIUS Zentrum für Interdisziplinäre Risiko- und Innovationsforschung der Universität,

Media library

This site uses third-party website tracking technologies to provide its services. I agree to this and can revoke or change my consent at any time with effect for the future.